Google changed 76% of title tags in John McAlpin’s study for Search Engine Land, which tracked Google results in the first quarter of 2025. In the titles Google changed, it kept only 35% of the original words.
So when someone tells you product page SEO is about “writing good title tags” and “keeping meta descriptions under 160 characters,” they’re telling you to optimise something Google is going to change anyway.
That doesn’t mean title tags don’t matter. It means understanding why Google rewrites them, and how to write the ones it doesn’t touch, matters far more than hitting a character count.
When Affilino audits a Shopify store, product page titles are one of the first checks: whether they are missing, duplicated, or aimed at the wrong keywords. Shopify also has two separate title fields that do two different jobs, and the difference matters.
This is how Affilino approaches product page SEO.
Key facts
- A Search Engine Land study by John McAlpin (first quarter of 2025) found Google changed 76% of title tags and kept 35% of the original words in the titles it changed.
- A Zyppy study by Cyrus Shepard of 80,959 title tags (early 2022) found Google rewrote 61.6% of them.
- In the Zyppy study, titles of 51 to 60 characters were rewritten 39% to 42% of the time, and titles over 60 characters had a greater than 76% chance of being rewritten.
- Affilino did not run either study: the 76% and 35% figures are John McAlpin’s (published by Search Engine Land), and the 61.6% and length figures are Cyrus Shepard’s (published by Zyppy).
Source: Affilino, written by Anvesh Katuri, page updated 18 November 2026.
Product Pages and Collection Pages Rank for Different Keywords
This is the single most important thing to understand before you touch a product page title tag.
Search any broad commercial keyword in your niche. “Men’s running shoes.” “Organic face cream.” “Leather crossbody bag.” Count how many first-page results are retailers’ collection and category pages rather than individual products.
Product pages rank for something different. Long-tail, product-specific queries. “Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 41 review.” “CeraVe moisturising cream 16oz.” “Blue merino wool crew neck sweater men’s.” Lower volume per keyword, but the person searching already knows what they want. They’re ready to buy.
We see store owners stuff broad commercial terms into their product page title tags all the time. “Men’s Running Shoes” as the title of a specific Nike Pegasus product page. That keyword belongs on the collection page. The product page should target the specific product name and its differentiators.
Every recommendation in this article follows from this distinction. Product pages need a long-tail keyword strategy, not a broad commercial one.
How Google Handles Your Title Tags
Most SEO guides will tell you to keep your title tags under 60 characters and include your target keyword. That’s fine as far as it goes. But it skips the part where Google changes your title tag in most search results.
A Zyppy study of 80,959 title tags by Cyrus Shepard, with data from early 2022, found Google rewrote 61.6% of them. John McAlpin’s Q1 2025 study for Search Engine Land put the figure at 76%. The two studies used different samples, so the gap is two snapshots rather than a measured trend. Either way, Google decides what most product pages say in search results.
Understanding how to write the titles Google keeps is worth more than any character-count formula.
How to Write Titles That Google Doesn’t Touch
Match your H1 to your title tag. The Zyppy study found that matching the H1 to the title “typically dropped the degree of rewriting across the board.” On Shopify, your product title is the H1. If your SEO title says something completely different, Google can build its rewrite from the H1 instead.
Stay in the 51-60 character range. In the Zyppy study, titles of 51 to 60 characters were rewritten 39% to 42% of the time, while titles over 60 characters had a greater than 76% chance of being rewritten. In McAlpin’s study, the titles Google left unchanged averaged 44.47 characters. Separately, Backlinko’s study of about 4 million Google results, by Brian Dean, found pages with title tags of 40 to 60 characters had a 33.3% higher click-through rate than pages outside that range.
Drop the brand name unless your brand IS the search query. In McAlpin’s study, removing the brand name was Google’s most common change, at 63% of the titles it changed. Shopify themes such as Dawn append ”– Store Name” by default, and on most product pages those characters add nothing.
Use dashes, not pipes or brackets. In the Zyppy study, Google removed the dashes from 19.7% of titles that used them and removed or replaced the pipes in 41.0% of titles that used pipes, while titles containing brackets were rewritten 77.6% of the time. If you’re separating elements in your title tag, dashes are the safest choice.
Google truncates titles by pixel width, not character count, and does not publish a fixed limit. A “W” takes up much more space than an “i.” The 51-60 character range accounts for average widths, but if your product names are full of wide characters, go shorter.
Shopify Has Two Title Fields, and Most Store Owners Only Use One
Shopify has two separate fields for every product:
Product Title is the H1 on the page. What shoppers see. Should be clean and customer-friendly. “Blue Merino Crew Neck Sweater.”
SEO Title lives under “Search engine listing preview” in admin. Becomes the <title> tag. What Google shows in search results. Can be different. “Blue Merino Wool Crew Neck Sweater – Men’s.”
The H1 sells to the person on the page. The meta title sells in the SERP. Different audiences, different jobs. But they need to be close enough that Google doesn’t see a mismatch and rewrite the title using the H1 instead.
Our formula for product page titles: lead with the specific product name, add one or two long-tail qualifiers, use a dash if you need a separator. Keep to 50-55 characters.
“Waterproof Hiking Boots – Gore-Tex Lined, Men’s” (49 characters). “Vitamin C Serum 20% – Brightening, Sensitive Skin” (50 characters). “Merino Wool Crew Neck – Blue, Men’s” (36 characters).
Meta Descriptions: Google Rewrites Most of Them Too
An Ahrefs study by Michal Pecánek (2020), comparing snippets for 20,000 keywords, found Google rewrote meta descriptions 62.78% of the time. Keeping your description within the recommended length did not reduce the rewrite rate: across 192,656 pages in the same study, Google rewrote 61.46% of too-long descriptions and 63.69% of the rest.
Write one anyway. When Google does use your description, it shows it as written, and a description with transactional details (price, availability, shipping) gives the shopper a reason to click on the searches where Google keeps it.
Google does not publish a length limit for descriptions; it truncates by pixel width. Affilino keeps the key details in the first 120 characters so they survive on mobile.
For product pages, include: a specific differentiator (what makes this product worth clicking over the other 9 results), the price if it’s competitive (filters out window shoppers, attracts ready buyers), and a soft CTA (“Free NZ shipping,” “See all colours”).
“Handmade leather wallet with RFID blocking, 8 card slots, coin pocket. Full-grain Italian leather. $89. Free NZ shipping.” That’s 120 characters. Specific. Transactional. Worth clicking.
For stores with hundreds of products, hand-write descriptions for the top 20% by revenue. Then optimise descriptions for products ranking positions 11-30 in Search Console. Those are strike-distance keywords where a better meta description can lift CTR enough to push them onto page 1. Template the rest.
Product Descriptions: What Google’s Quality System Expects
Every guide says “write unique product descriptions.” We’re not going to rehash that. You know not to copy the manufacturer’s text. Here’s what most guides don’t tell you.
What Google’s quality rater guidelines say about generic descriptions
The January 2025 update to Google’s Search Quality Rater Guidelines tells raters to give the Lowest rating to pages whose main content is copied, paraphrased or generated with AI with little effort, originality or added value (Search Engine Land). Raters do not set rankings; the guidelines describe the content Google’s ranking systems aim to reward.
What falls short: thin descriptions, manufacturer-copied content shared across dozens of retailer sites, AI-generated generic descriptions that don’t add anything the manufacturer spec sheet doesn’t already say.
What the guidelines ask for: first-hand experience with the product (specific details only someone who handled it would know), information that genuinely helps a purchase decision (sizing guidance, material comparisons, real-world use cases), and supporting content like FAQs and buying guides.
Add an FAQ section to product pages
Q&A content naturally uses the exact language buyers search with. “Is this safe for sensitive skin?” “What size should I order if I’m between sizes?” “Does this work with [compatible product]?” These are real queries you’d never target intentionally, and they come from people close to buying.
Source 3-5 questions from Google’s “People Also Ask” for your product type. Keep answers concise, under 50 words. Since August 2023 Google shows FAQ rich results only for “well-known, authoritative government and health websites”, so on a store the value is in the answers themselves.
Description length depends on the product, not an arbitrary target
Word count on its own doesn’t rank a page; what the words cover does. Match length to product complexity.
For simple, impulse-buy products under $50 (accessories, basic apparel), Affilino writes concise bullet points focused on key benefits. For complex, high-consideration products (electronics, appliances, anything over $200), Affilino writes detailed descriptions of up to 1,000 words, because buyers need more information before committing.
Affilino’s default for most products is 300-400 words of substantive content. Skip lines like “this beautiful product is perfect for you” and give actual information: materials, specifications, sizing details, use cases, care instructions.
Customer reviews are SEO content

Reviews add new text to a product page as they come in. They generate natural long-tail keyword variations in language you’d never write yourself, and they describe real use of the product, the first-hand experience Google’s quality guidelines ask for.
Star ratings in search results need review markup Google can read (see the schema section below). Curate reviews that naturally contain your target keywords and feature them prominently. Not buried in a tab. Visible on the page.
Cover the semantic field around your product
Go beyond repeating your primary keyword. Cover the semantic neighbourhood around the product: materials, use cases, compatible accessories, brand context, performance specifications. If you sell a hiking boot, don’t just repeat “waterproof hiking boot.” Cover Gore-Tex, Vibram soles, ankle support, terrain types, break-in period, weight.
Image SEO: Your LCP Element and Your Visual Search Entry Point

You already know to add alt text. Good. The stuff most guides skip is more interesting.
File naming matters and most stores ignore it. Rename before uploading. Google’s image SEO documentation says the filename “can give Google very light clues about the subject matter of the image.” “IMG_4521.jpg” tells Google nothing. “red-leather-crossbody-bag-front-view.jpg” tells it what the photo shows. Hyphens between words. Descriptive. Keyword-relevant.
Alt text basics: describe what’s in the image (“Women’s red leather crossbody bag with gold chain strap”), keep under 125 characters, include the product keyword naturally, don’t start with “Image of” or “Photo of.”
Your main product image is the usual LCP element. Google’s web.dev guidance sets a good Largest Contentful Paint at 2.5 seconds or less. Tell your developer: the main product image must load eagerly (not lazy-loaded), and it should be properly sized for the viewport rather than loading a 2048px image on a 400px mobile screen. Shopify serves WebP or AVIF automatically when the shopper’s browser supports them (Shopify Help Center), so format isn’t the issue. Size and loading priority are.
Multiple images in multiple aspect ratios. Google’s merchant listing structured data documentation recommends multiple high-resolution images in 16x9, 4x3 and 1x1 aspect ratios. Most stores provide one square image.
Visual search is large. Google said in October 2024 that Lens is used for nearly 20 billion visual searches every month. Product images with clean backgrounds, good lighting and multiple angles give Lens a clear match.
The Three Data Sources Controlling Your Product Visibility
Google doesn’t just use your product page to determine what your product is and where to show it. It uses three data sources, and they don’t carry equal weight.
On-page content: what’s visible on your product page. Text, images, prices.
Structured data: your JSON-LD schema markup. The machine-readable version of your product information.
Merchant Centre product feed: the data you send to Google Shopping.
The part most people miss: which source controls which output is not equal.
Your product title in free listing grids (the “Popular Products” carousel, the Shopping tab) comes directly from your Merchant Centre feed. Not from your page title. Not from your schema. Your feed title.
When the price in your feed doesn’t match the price on the product page, Merchant Centre can disapprove the product for a price mismatch.
When these three sources tell Google different things (different names, different prices, different availability), Google has to choose which to trust, and mismatches can take products out of Shopping results. Consistency across all three is not optional.
What Shopify’s schema gives Google by default (and what’s missing)

Shopify’s built-in structured_data filter outputs the basics: product name, description, image, URL, brand/vendor, price, currency, availability. For products with variants, Shopify’s documentation says it outputs a ProductGroup with individual Product entries (added in mid-2024).
What the filter’s documented output does not show, and what Google lists for merchant listings:
aggregateRating and review. Without these, you don’t get star ratings in search results. In a SearchPilot test published in February 2021 by Emily Potter, adding review structured data (without price) to one customer’s product pages produced an estimated 20% uplift in organic traffic; adding price and review markup together was inconclusive.
sku, gtin and mpn. Check whether your theme outputs them. Google lists them as recommended properties, and complete product identifiers matter for Google Shopping free listings.
shippingDetails and hasMerchantReturnPolicy. Google lists these as recommended, not required, properties for merchant listing rich results, the ones that show shipping cost and return window directly in search.
Have your developer add these. But be careful: the most common mistake we see is stores installing a third-party SEO app that injects its own Product schema alongside Shopify’s built-in schema. You end up with two conflicting sets of product data on the same page. Google doesn’t know which to trust. One source of truth. Always test with Google’s Rich Results Test.
There’s also a reported issue in the Shopify Community, open since July 2024: the structured_data filter gives every product variant the same @id instead of a unique identifier. Users in the thread report that Google’s Rich Results Test finds only the first variant, and that the new tags shipped with Dawn 15.0.2. If you sell products with variants, have your developer verify each variant gets a unique identifier in the schema.
Google Merchant Centre and the Top Quality Store Badge
Google Merchant Centre enables free product listings in the Shopping tab, the “Popular Products” carousel in regular search results, and Google Image product annotations. Most Shopify stores either don’t connect to Merchant Centre at all or connect but don’t optimise their feed.
Product disapprovals from Merchant Centre can silently hide your products from shoppers. Many merchants don’t even know it’s happening. If you haven’t checked your Merchant Centre for disapprovals recently, do it today.
Your product page SEO and your Merchant Centre feed are not separate activities. The feed title is what shows in free listing grids, not your page title. Google recommends including the brand name in feed product titles, even though McAlpin’s study found brand removal is Google’s most common change to organic title tags. The rules are different for each surface. Include GTINs and barcodes for full eligibility. And keep prices, availability, and product names consistent across your page, your schema, and your feed.
What the Top Quality Store badge is
Google’s Top Quality Store help page says the badge goes to “the businesses with the highest ratings”, judged on data such as shipping and returns policies, user ratings, and the quality and accessibility of the store’s website.
Check your store quality in Merchant Centre. Higher-resolution product images and faster page speed are the parts of that score fully within your control.
What to Do With Out-of-Stock and Discontinued Products
Every ecommerce store deals with this. Products go out of stock, get discontinued, are seasonal. Most store owners either delete the product (losing all accumulated backlinks, internal links, and ranking signals) or leave it up with no stock and no alternative, which frustrates visitors and increases bounce rate.
This is the decision framework we use.
Temporarily out of stock (coming back): Keep the page live. Show “Notify me when back in stock” or allow pre-orders. Update the availability in your schema to OutOfStock or BackOrder. The page retains all its ranking signals and is ready to perform the moment stock returns.
Permanently discontinued with a replacement: 301 redirect to the replacement product. All link equity transfers to the new page.
Permanently discontinued without a replacement: 301 redirect to the parent collection page when it sells close alternatives. Google’s John Mueller has said redirects of removed products to the home page, a category page or an unrelated product can be treated as soft 404s (Search Engine Roundtable), so if no close alternative exists, let the page return a 404 instead.
Seasonal products: Keep the page live year-round. Update the description to indicate the product returns next season. The page retains its rankings and doesn’t need to start from zero each year.
What NOT to do: don’t delete the product and let it 404. Don’t redirect to the homepage: Google treats those redirects as soft 404s, so the old page’s signals are lost. Don’t leave a dead “Out of Stock” page with no alternative.
When Product Variants Need Their Own Pages
Shopify treats variants (size, colour, material) as options on a single product page. Each variant gets a URL parameter (?variant=12345) but all canonicalise back to the base product URL. Variants cannot have their own unique title tags, meta descriptions, or H1s.
This is perfectly fine for size variants. Nobody searches “Nike Pegasus size 10” independently of “Nike Pegasus.”
It’s not fine when individual variants have meaningful search demand of their own. The test is simple: search the variant in Google. “Red leather handbag” versus “blue leather handbag.” Do the SERPs show different results? Is there enough search volume to justify a separate page? If yes, that variant deserves its own product listing, with its own title, description, images, and schema.
Common cases where separate products make sense: colours with distinct search volume (“black running shoes” versus “white running shoes”), different materials (“leather wallet” versus “canvas wallet”), different formulations (“vitamin C serum 10%” versus “vitamin C serum 20%”).
Google supports product variant structured data (ProductGroup with variesBy and hasVariant), so variant data in your feed, schema and page content can line up. Most stores only handle one of these three layers. Handle all three.
How to Diagnose Product Page Cannibalisation
This catches out more Shopify stores than you’d expect. Your “Running Shoes” collection page and your “Nike Pegasus” product page both end up trying to rank for “Nike running shoes.” Neither wins because they split Google’s signals. We’ve covered how internal linking can reinforce rather than compete, but the diagnosis starts in Search Console.
Go to the Performance report. Filter by a specific keyword. Click the query, then switch to the Pages tab. If one URL receives more than 90% of impressions, you’re fine. If impressions split 60/40 or worse across multiple URLs, you have a cannibalisation problem.
The fix: collection pages target broad, category-level keywords (“women’s running shoes”). Product pages target specific, long-tail keywords (“Nike Pegasus 41 women’s road running shoe”). Never optimise a product page and a collection page for the same keyword. Link from the product page TO its parent collection using the broad keyword as anchor text. This signals to Google which page is the authority for the broader term. Our SEO audit checklist covers cannibalisation detection as part of the full review.
FAQ
How do I optimise my Shopify product page for SEO?
Start with the SEO title field. Most store owners never touch it. Set a unique SEO title (50-55 characters, matching your H1 closely), write a meta description with transactional signals (price, differentiator, CTA), add 300-400 words of unique product description, and ensure every image has descriptive alt text and a proper filename. Then check that your structured data is complete and consistent with your Merchant Centre feed.
Does Google rewrite Shopify product title tags?
Yes. In John McAlpin’s Q1 2025 study for Search Engine Land, Google changed 76% of title tags, and removing the brand name was the most common change (63% of changed titles). The study covered Google results in general, not Shopify stores alone. To reduce rewrites: match your H1 closely to your SEO title, stay within 51-60 characters, and use dashes instead of pipes or brackets.
Does Shopify automatically add structured data to product pages?
Yes, but it’s incomplete. Shopify generates basic Product schema (name, price, availability, brand). Its documented output shows no review or rating data, shipping details or return policy, and you should check whether your theme outputs product identifiers (GTIN, SKU). Google lists all of these as recommended properties for merchant listing rich results.
Should the product title and SEO title be the same on Shopify?
Close, but not necessarily identical. The product title (H1) should be clean and customer-friendly. The SEO title can include additional keyword qualifiers. But they should be closely aligned. When they diverge too much, Google can rewrite the title tag from the H1; the Zyppy study found that matching them reduced rewriting.
How long should a Shopify product description be for SEO?
300-400 words for most products. Complex, high-consideration items (electronics, appliances) benefit from up to 1,000 words. Simple impulse-buy items can be shorter with bullet points. Match description length to product complexity, not an arbitrary word count.
What happens to SEO when I delete a product on Shopify?
You lose all accumulated backlinks, internal links, and ranking signals. Instead of deleting, 301 redirect the URL: to a replacement product if one exists, or to the parent collection page if not. For seasonal products, keep the page live year-round and update the description.
How do I get my Shopify products to show up in Google Shopping for free?
Install the Google & YouTube Shopify app to connect your Merchant Centre. Ensure product data is complete: titles, descriptions, GTINs/barcodes, high-quality images, accurate pricing. Add missing schema properties (shipping, returns, reviews) to your product pages. Check for product disapprovals in Merchant Centre. They silently hide your products.
Product page SEO on Shopify is not about following a checklist of title tag lengths and meta description formulas. Google rewrites most of them anyway. It’s about understanding how Google evaluates your product pages across three data sources, giving it the structured data it needs for rich results and free listings, and targeting the right keywords: the long-tail, product-specific ones that your collection pages can’t capture.
Getting this right is the core of the product page work an Auckland Shopify SEO agency does: showing up in Shopping carousels, earning star ratings in search results, and reaching searchers on surfaces competitors leave empty.
Affilino is an Auckland-based Shopify SEO agency for online stores.
If you want us to audit your product pages and build an SEO strategy around what’s holding your store back, book a strategy call. We’ll pull up your Search Console data, check your schema, and show you exactly where the gaps are.
Keep Reading
- Shopify Collection Page SEO: How to Optimise Collections, collection pages rank for the commercial keywords product pages can’t
- Shopify Duplicate Content: URL Structure and Canonical Fixes, canonical URL issues directly affect your product page indexation
- Shopify Internal Linking: Strategy and Anchor Text Guide, how to send authority to your product pages
- Shopify SEO Audit Checklist: 51 Checks, Step by Step, the full audit we run on every client store
- Shopify Product Page: 12 Add-to-Cart Fixes, the conversion side of product page optimisation